On Habit and Heart: Alternative Liturgical Services and Traditionalism in the Church

-
After the final hymn echoed through the church, Pastor Neil stood by the door for the traditional Sunday handshake. But not everyone was leaving the Church; a member who stayed behind for some minutes approached the pastor and said,

"Pastor, can I share something? The service today—it felt a bit… off," he began timidly.

Pastor Neil nodded, inviting him to elaborate. "Of course. What do you mean?"

"Well," the member replied, "it didn’t feel as uplifting as usual. It’s like it lacked… connection or relevance. I’m not sure everyone really felt moved."

Pastor Neil smiled thoughtfully. "That’s an interesting observation. Did we have the Word? The Sacraments?"

"Yes, of course," the member answered. "But I think people expect something more engaging, something that speaks to where they are. It’s important for the service to feel relevant

 "Well, here we entering and interesting conversation about worship life of the Church. Do you have time for a coffee?"
 
In many congregations, discussions about worship often centre around tradition, balancing reverence for historical liturgy with the desire for contemporary expression. The rise of blended or contemporary services, designed to "meet people where they are," introduces its own set of challenges and risks. While innovation in worship can be an opportunity to engage with modern culture, it also carries the danger of slipping into a form of traditionalism that prioritizes style over substance.

Just as rigid adherence to historical forms can devolve into traditionalism, so too can an overemphasis on cultural relevance or personal connection. This type of "contemporary traditionalism" risks turning worship into a product designed to elicit emotional responses or cater to preferences, rather than serving as an encounter with Christ through Word and Sacrament.

Martin Luther emphasized that worship is not about what we bring to God but about what He gives to us. The Divine Service is fundamentally Christ-centred: God coming to His people through Word and Sacrament to offer forgiveness, life, and salvation. Whether expressed in the chants of the liturgy or the melodies of modern praise songs, worship must be rooted in these means of grace, not in our feelings, preferences, or cultural trends.

Tradition vs. Traditionalism

In Lutheran worship, tradition functions as a framework for proclaiming the Gospel, connecting the Church across time and space. It is a tool that ensures the focus remains on Christ’s redemptive work. Contemporary traditionalism, however, can prioritize stylistic elements—upbeat music, emotionally charged sermons, or casual atmospheres—over the theological integrity of the service.

For instance, a blended service might aim to appeal to multiple generations by incorporating Alternative Liturgical Services. While this can be a meaningful approach, problems arise when the focus shifts from the content of the Gospel to the experience of the worshipper. A service designed primarily to "connect with people" risks overshadowing the unchanging truth of God’s Word with fleeting emotional engagement. This mirrors the pitfalls of historical traditionalism: elevating form above substance.

Jesus addressed a similar issue with the Pharisees, who prioritized outward appearances of piety over true devotion to God: “These people honour me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me” (Matthew 15:8, ESV). Likewise, contemporary traditionalism can turn worship into a performance—valued for its ability to entertain or inspire—rather than a means of receiving God’s gifts.

Worship as Encounter, Not Entertainment

The essence of worship is God’s action: His Word proclaimed, His forgiveness delivered, His people nourished in the Sacrament. When services become overly focused on creating a "spiritual" or "relevant" experience, the danger is that the worshipper's response becomes the measure of success, rather than faithfulness to the Gospel.

As Pastor Neil might remind us: "Worship isn’t about how we feel; it’s about what God does for us. Whether the music stirs us emotionally or not, Christ is present, giving us His Word and His grace."

Contemporary traditionalism can also mask deeper issues. Just as rigid adherence to historical forms might serve as a coping mechanism for spiritual insecurity, an overemphasis on modern worship styles might be a reflex of the same mechanism, which is not aligned with the Word. Other reasons for that include, for example, a desire to "fix" declining attendance; the need to act as a "super-spiritual" person on Sunday as a way to cover the sinful way in which one lives their life  from Monday to Saturday; still, to address personal struggles by doubling down in efforts to please God and others. These approaches risk obscuring the central truth that salvation is by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone.

The same principle applies to the concern of the church member: "I don’t know if the service was spiritual enough." Pastor Neil might answer: "It’s not the music, or the order of service, that makes worship spiritual. It’s the Word of God that brings life and the presence of Christ that transforms us. Whether in hymns or modern songs, the Gospel is what makes our Service spiritual, true and life giving."

Blended and Alternative Liturgical Services services can be a beautiful way to help different generations to worship together while still holding fast to the Lutheran theology. As they are grounded in the essentials of God's Service, they will lead the congregational to keep her worship life in a Christ-centred way.

"Thanks for the chat, Pastor", said the member, as he prepared to go about his Sunday. "I still have to think more about it, but I appreciate your openness to talk."

"My pleasure", smiled Pastor Neil. "I appreciate your desire to have a living and active congregation, that is good and we should cultivate it. Always keeping in mind though that  it’s not about the style or form, but about the substance. Our Service points us to Christ and we receive His gifts through Word and Sacrament. As long as these are central, our worship will always point us back to the cross and the empty tomb, where we find the essence of God's Service to us and our response to Him!"

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Worship life: music, essence and forms

-
Image
The Worship Service is an area of both rich blessing and high tension for the Church. This has happened many times, and still happens mainly when form and content, which are both important, get confused and one takes the place of the other. However, the Divine Service is a gateway to the mission of the Church,  and the high point of congregational life - even though the life of a congregation is not defined solely by the service or the style of worship but it appears in different areas of its life. T herefore, it is always in need of attention, practice and care in whichever ways and means it is practised and celebrated.   In this essay, we reflect on the musical content and its importance in the Divine Service, and the use of Alternative Liturgical Services as a form of strengthening the Lutheran Church Musical content The musical content is normally one of the most sensitive topics connected to Divine Service. which needs attention, care and understanding in every way it is utiliz
Read more

We stand firm in our faith - Hymn and Compositional notes

-
Image
This is the official hymn of the 2018-2022 quadrennium of the Lutheran Church in Brazil (IELB). It was composed by Tom Pacheco, Rev. Paulo Brum and I, and it sings the Church's motto for that 4-year span, "We stand firm on our faith" Later, Pastor Brum and I wrote the English version of it. Here are the lyrics, of the hymn, and also notes about the composition which underline and reinforce the message, as well as enhance the hymn listening and singing experience. *Note: in the video, the lyrics are slightly different (1st English version) compared to the lyrics below, which are the final version of the Hymn.   WE STAND FIRM IN OUR FAITH 1. Jesus Christ, our Lord, called as Your flock, we delight in hearing Your Voice teaching to our hearts what Your Word imparts. Law and Gospel, unchanging Light. We stand firm in our faith in You, our Saviour, The Way! You’re the Bread, the Door, Brother, Vine and more; Shepherd in whom we are bless’d. 2. Father, move our hearts, move
Read more

THE LUTHERAN SERMON FROM THE RECEIVER'S VIEWPOINT

-
Image
This is my scientific article presented as the final paper for my Social Communication Degree in 2011. It is written not from the Theological, but rather from the Communication perspective, particularly in the field of Reception Studies.   ABSTRACT This article verified how a contemporary Lutheran sermon in a Sunday Worship Service is accepted and perceived by the receivers, members of St. Paul Lutheran Church in Canoas, RS, observing how the sermon content was identified and what is the interpretation of the message. Authors from both Theology and Communication fields represented the theoretical approach. The methodological approach was qualitative using a questionnaire and an in-depth interview. Results indicated that Lutheran Christians identified the main content of a sermon however with both redefinition and amplification of its intended meaning within their personal experience.   KEYWORDS: Lutheran sermon, Audience, Reception.   THE LUTHERAN SERMON FROM THE RECEIVER'S
Read more

Against the necessity of proving that God exists

-
Image
            When you go to a Dinosaur Museum no one spends much time trying to prove to you that they were alive millions of years ago.   The learning process there is based on that premise. The same happens when it comes to Astronomy. Nobody in the area is heavily occupied with proving that the Universe is 13 billion years-old and counting. The work is done taking this for granted. Similarly, when people attend a football or soccer game, hardly anyone has as their primary goal to convince fans that this is an emotionally incredible, satisfying experience. The whole event is built upon that assumption. Also, in those contexts people usually can’t hide evident conflicting information or bad facts and results to make the teaching/institution look good all the time. Even these are believed to add to the overall reliability and profit of the experience.             The same was held as valid for the existence of God in many historical circumstances. The Reformation Period is and an examp
Read more

The Liturgy of the Lutheran Service - Video

-
Image
This video was a production for the "Toque de Vida"(Touch of Life) program, a daily show on ULBRA TV, the longest running TV Program in an "open signal" station in Brazilian Lutheranism (2004 -     ) In 2008, we started to record Lutheran Services and air them every Sunday, 8AM-9AM on ULBRA TV. On a given Sunday, instead of airing a Service, we thought of explaining the Liturgical content of the Traditional Service in a way that people unfamiliar with the Traditional Lutheran Service could learn more about it. To illustrate the parts of the liturgy we used footage of regular Services recorded in three different Chapels of "St Paul" Lutheran Church in Canoas (now "Mighty Fortress" Lutheran Church), including the Campus Chapel to which, together with Campus Ministry, I was called to lead the Church planting in 2004. You can check out this Special Program by clicking on the video.
Read more